Archive for February, 2009

Where’s the discussion?

Saturday, February 28th, 2009

I attended the budget workshop on Wednesday night.  Typically a workshop would be held so that a full discussion can be had where the only focus is that one item.  The budget is a huge and complicated item and I thought the idea was to discuss all options on Wednesday so that a decision could be made at the regular board meeting on March 9.  I guess not.

After extensive presentations from both FCMAT and Ron Lebs, the board asked only a few brief questions and then adjourned to closed session with NO discussion.  Nothing.  We as parents have no idea what these trustees are thinking.  There was no prioritizing, no negotiation, nothing.  It makes no sense.

I’ve since heard rumors that the trustees know exactly what they plan to do on the 9th but how can that be when there has been no OPEN and TRANSPARANT discussion?  Having open dialogue last Wednesday was critical so that parents could judge where the trustees were leaning and then know how to respond.  This is supposed to be a process that involves the parents and even the teachers and so far it has not.  Even after all of the responses on line (at least 1,500) we don’t know what trustees think of those suggestions.  They absolutely refuse to adequately communicate with us and I find that truly disturbing!

Budget Workshop

Monday, February 23rd, 2009

The board of trustees has scheduled another budget workshop for Wednesday, February 25 at the district office.  There are rumors of all kinds of cuts for next year and even things like eliminating Kindergarten and cutting high school academies are being considered — not too popular as you can imagine.  I went to the website today to print the agenda and noticed that it has been completed redesigned.  That had to have cost a pretty penny.  Money that certainly could have been spent in the classroom instead.  What was wrong with the old website?  Maybe not the flashiest but it was easy to use and full of valuable information.  Who authorized it being re-done?  Certainly not our superintendent since he is still on paid leave.  And speaking of leave, there are several closed session items including public dismissal and appointment of public employee.  Hmmm.  Should be interesting.  Hope lots of people attend.

Beyond the Blackboard - February 8, 2009

Tuesday, February 10th, 2009

Residents Meet with Local Officials

About 200 local residents turned out in San Clemente last week for a public forum to learn more about their city and schools.  The event, sponsored by the local PTA, was held at San Clemente High School and featured guest speakers Mayor Lori Donchak, City Council Member Bob Baker, CUSD Trustee Anna Bryson, and CUSD Trustee Jack Brick.

It was the first public appearance with open questions by CUSD trustees since the election and a good opportunity for interested residents to get answers to questions.  While the audience was a friendly one, they asked some tough questions.  Both trustees refused to answer any questions relating to the Superintendent and his administrative leave stating legal reasons.

On the subject of joint use projects, Mayor Donchak thought the city and the district were working well together but cautioned the budget crisis would probably not allow for anything new this year.  She did mention that the city will be reviewing the general plan this year for the first time in over 15 years and that it was an excellent opportunity for residents to share their priorities with the city.  Trustee Brick mentioned that the school district is updating the master plan for facilities in CUSD.

Residents wanted to know where the current trustees stood on supporting the dual immersion program at Las Palmas and the safe routes to schools.  Trustee Bryson assured them that the operations department was working to make schools safe.  Mayor Donchak spoke about a new sidewalk coming for the upper campus of San Clemente High School.  She also mentioned that the city was applying for another “safe routes to school” grant.  Council member Baker fully supports the dual immersion/2-way language program at Las Palmas.

The extension of La Pata is a big issue in San Clemente and residents asked for an update on the status of the roadway from the city and for information about boundary changes from the district.  The Mayor supports the La Pata completion but said that the final decision on where the road will go has not been made and there is a funding issue.  She said that the earliest estimated completion would be in 2015.  The trustees in attendance said that any boundary changes would go through the full process with input from all affected.

Concerns over the budget cuts and how that will affect programs like International Baccalaureate, Athletics, the Auto Academy, TLC, and other programs were posed to trustees.  Bryson said that “everything is on the table” and it was impossible to guarantee the future of programs.  Another question was how the cuts would affect teachers and their jobs.  Trustees were vague in responding citing the state budget and its uncertainty.

While Trustees refused to answer questions specific to Superintendent Carter, the audience wanted to know what the board’s plans were for getting a new superintendent and what he hiring criteria was.   Standards like excellence in curriculum, knowledge of students, talented, and a quality person were all mentioned.  Trustee Brick said they needed to move quickly to get this done.

The question regarding the rumors about the trustees having a “social agenda” and their ties to the Education Alliance was also brought up that night.  Trustees did a pretty good job of dancing around that issue without ever actually answering the question leaving some I spoke with frustrated.  Trustees also skirted the issue regarding a conflict of interest between them and their campaign supporters who have lawsuits pending against the district.

While all the questions and issues were not fully addressed, the evening was a successful one and everyone in attendance appreciated the opportunity to ask questions and participate.  The guest speakers also expressed appreciation to those in attendance.  More of these events should be held throughout our district to give people the opportunity to better know those who represent them.  Stay tuned for more updates on school issues in Beyond the Blackboard.

The Truth is Out

Sunday, February 1st, 2009

For the past month, our school district has been operating with no Superintendent.  In their worst decision to date, Trustees placed Superintendent Carter on paid administrative leave on January 6.  They gave no reason at the time and still have no explanation.  An anonymous list of “10 reasons to fire Carter” was widely circulated just after the decision by recall supporters to try to justify the decision but as to be expected.  The reasons were not true.

In a Register article, reporter Scott Martindale uncovers at least one of them that the trustees had tried to build their case on.  I know that this is not the only thing on the list that was wrong but here is a link to the article so that you can see exactly what our school board is up to.

http://www.ocregister.com/articles/contract-trustees-carter-2294908-teachers-district